The Art of the Trial: Closing Arguments

Brian Hennigan Art of the Trial: Closing Arguments

In his column on Art of the Trial: Closing Arguments, Mr. Hennigan, who is a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers, shares tips on organizing the content of a closing argument, resisting the urge to rest, and how to avoid making jurors giggle in disbelief.

By Brian J. Hennigan

The trial is over. All witnesses have finished their testimony. The exhibits have either been received into evidence or never will be admitted. The trial court has reviewed with counsel the jury instructions. The jury is assembled in the box. The trial judge turns to you, telling the jury that it will first hear from plaintiff’s counsel, in closing argument. You stand, turn to the jury, and…

Clearly, this is not the time to start thinking about the form and substance of your closing argument. You have doubtlessly studied the subject before the day in court. You have researched the subject, and probably run though the argument with friends — or at least to yourself during the long commutes to the courthouse during the trial. Depending on the size of the case and the anxiety level of your client, you have likely presented the closing argument to mock juries to assess how a jury will respond to your key points.

I have tried approximately 50 cases in federal and state court, as a federal prosecutor, a criminal defense counsel, as well as criminal and civil cases on both the plaintiff and defense side. There is no “one size fits all” formula for presenting an effective closing argument. But, there are a common number of practice tips than attorney should keep in mind in designing and presenting an effective closing argument.

Read more in: The Daily Journal

Share on: